Benny wrote:My original idea was to purchase a proco rat but after hearing the box of rock, the rat sounded like a chinese copy of a boss ds1.
Hahaha this is such an evocative description....
Of course, that's why some folks (including me) like the Rat.
They're completely different devices. They're not intended to really fill the same role. The Box of Rock is supposed to be more amp-like than the Rat, like a top of the line overdrive with extra gain. The Rat was never intended to be anything but artificial- it wasn't marketed as a "JTM on 10," it was sold as something that'll do what your amp CAN'T do. The Rat is also one of very few pedals for which I give any credence to the "the old circuit was better" stuff. Okay, one of very few except BOSS - seems like every revision they make is to make the circuit worse. And I don't consider the Dunlop Fuzz Face to be a Fuzz Face.

but yeah - most pedals, if they give up any unidentifiable "mojo," they make up for it by better bypass (whether T.B. or a better buffer), lower noise, and more unit-to-unit consistency - Big Muffs, perfect example. You might find 1 of 10 old ram's head or triangle Muffs that sound amazing; the rest are thin and noisy and you'd never know why they became popular. Outside of those outliers, I'd take a current production BMP with Tone Wicker over any of 'em. The "best" Muffs ain't even made by EHX (just like the best Fuzz Faces and Rangemasters weren't made by John Dallas). The Rat is a different beast entirely. The CP Rat is pretty much a turd, a generic "distortion" box, interchangeable with the kind of stuff you can get for $25 at Wal-Mart. It's Behringer, Rogue quality distortion. The old Rat was something special - but something way different from the Box of Rock.
I'm a fuzz guy. I get my overdrive by turning up my amp. I wouldn't be in the market for many distortion pedals - the Rat, Box of Rock, and a really clean/well built example of the Ross/Distortion+/DOD 250 circuit would be pretty much it.
Congrats on your purchases. You sure didn't waste your time on anything that wasn't top-of-the-line. Those pedals should satisfy you for years.
"Country music must go on!" -- Austin J. Hall, September 11, 2001